FDA Describes Potential Hazards Associated with Species Substitution

Today FDA released the 4th edition of the Fish and Fishery Products Hazards and Controls Guidance document (Hazards Guide). Newly added to the guidance is confirmation that misidentification of species (i.e., species substitution) could result in a potential food safety hazard. Chapter Three of the Hazards Guide lists the potential species-related and process-related hazards in table format and includes the following information on species substitution.

Species substitution

Illicit substitution of one species for another may constitute economic fraud and/or misbranding violations of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act. Furthermore, species substitution may cause potential food safety hazards to be overlooked or misidentified by processors or end users, as shown in Table 3-1, The Effect of Misbranding Through Species Substitution on the Identification of Potential Species-Related Hazards. These examples are based on actual incidents of species substitution or misbranding.

Table 3-1

THE EFFECT OF MISBRANDING THROUGH SPECIES SUBSTITUTION ON THE IDENTIFICATION OF POTENTIAL SPECIES-RELATED HAZARDS

ACTUAL MARKET NAME OF PRODUCT

POTENTIAL SPECIES- RELATED HAZARDS ASSOCIATED WITH THE ACTUAL PRODUCT (FROM TABLE 3-2)

PRODUCT INAPPROPRIATELY LABELED AS

POTENTIAL SPECIES-RELATED HAZARDS THAT WOULD BE IDENTIFIED BASED ON INAPPROPRIATE SPECIES LABELING (FROM TABLE 3-2)

Escolar

Gempylotoxin Histamine

Sea bass

Parasites

Puffer fish

Tetrodotoxin Paralytic Shellfish Poisoning

Monkfish

Parasites

Spanish mackerel

Parasites Histamine Ciguatera Fish Poisoning

Kingfish

None

Basa

Environmental chemical contaminants and pesticides

Grouper

Parasites Ciguatera Fish Poisoning

Grouper

Parasites Ciguatera Fish Poisoning

Cod

Parasites